Costs a game changer for seabed gold and copper mining?
Industry analysts reckon seabed mining could transform the mining industry, its attractiveness riding on high ore grades and dwindling metal supplies elsewhere, but see operating costs as a major hurdle.
Posted: Friday , 09 Mar 2012
LONDON (Reuters) -
Touted as the mining world's next frontier, its attractiveness riding on high ore grades and dwindling metal supplies elsewhere, seabed mining will have to prove it can keep costs low to win over mainstream investors.
While the diamond industry has been mining off the Namibian shoreline for years, Toronto-listed Nautilus Minerals is expected to be the first commercial operation to extract metals such as copper and gold from the seabed.
Some analysts say the move could transform the mining industry in the way off-shore drilling gave access to new deposits in the oil and gas sector in the 1970s. But keeping operating costs low will be crucial to seabed mining's success, they warn.
Seafloor mining comes at a critical time for the industry. Copper ore grades are declining, forcing firms to mine in riskier areas, costs are rising and new projects have been slow to catch up with demand from emerging economies.
A Reuters survey late last year showed long-term price forecasts for copper have jumped by a fifth compared with the previous year on strong demand from emerging markets and rising production costs in a world of tight supply.
Long-term, or incentive, price forecasts are used to evaluate the feasibility and potential profitability of future projects.
Gold is also seen as lucrative to mine, with spot prices trading up almost 9 percent this year after hitting an all-time high at $1,920.30 an ounce in September 2011.
Founded by geologist-turned-journalist Julian Malnic in the late 1990s, Nautilus has permission to explore massive sulphide deposits in the floor of the Bismarck sea off the coast of Papua New Guinea for copper, gold, zinc and silver.
The firm is backed by high-profile investors, including global miner Anglo American Plc and Russia's largest iron ore miner Metalloinvest, controlled by Arsenal football club shareholder Alisher Usmanov.
"They (shareholders) recognise that if it works it's going to be a game changer for the mining industry in many respects because there is a lot of this stuff out there on the ocean floor," Numis analyst Andy Davidson said.
"It's almost a punt for those guys and I think that's the way a lot of investors look at this. This is a high-risk, potentially very high-reward speculative play."
COST IS KEY
Nautilus aims to start producing at Solwara 1 in the Bismarck sea, at a water depth of some 1,600 metres, in late 2013. It hopes to produce around 80,000 tonnes of copper and 150,000 ounces of gold per year, equivalent to a small mine.
"The initial resources at Solwara 1 will allow us to produce for two-three years and we will then move the production system to the next resource," Nautilus Chief Executive Steve Rogers told Reuters in an interview.
"Unlike land-based mining where you have got to completely build new infrastructure, one of the attractions here is we can move the vessel around in a very short space of time and begin production... at a low incremental cost."
Cost is an issue that analysts said will be key to the long-term viability of seafloor mining, including ore transportation costs if mining areas are located further away from land such as off the Eastern Pacific, between Hawaii and Mexico.
"You need to have some sort of offshore processing facility, which will be hugely expensive, or else you're transporting huge tonnages of material and the freight costs would be prohibitive," said Christine Meilton, principle consultant at CRU.
But the Solwara 1 project could be spared some of the higher transportation costs, Meilton said as the area is close to land.
Energy costs involved in lifting the ore and separating it from the water, will also be a factor closely monitored by analysts, in relation to every tonne of copper, or ounce of gold recovered.
Potential higher costs could be counterbalanced by higher grade ores as analysts estimate copper deposits on the seafloor are around 7 percent, compared with grades around 0.6 percent on land.
Gold grades of over 20 grammes a tonne have been discovered in some parts in Solwara 1, according to Nautilus.
"If it works, with a fairly reasonable contingency to the guidelines that they (Nautilus) have put out, it should be very cost efficient compared to land-based operations," said Numis' Davidson said.
"It will be relatively high costs in absolute terms on a per tonne of ore lifted, but because the ore is so rich in metals and the grade is so high, on a per unit of contained metal basis its comparable and cheap."
The high ore grades for copper on the sea floor is one of the main draws for seabed mining, said David Russell, Director of Global Resources at Ernst & Young, with shallow seabeds the best areas to mine for keeping costs low.
"It is much easier to operate in areas where there is relatively shallow seabed but would you be able to get permission to mine them?," he said.
Large-scale permission to mine on the sea floor is likely to face opposition from environmental campaigners and indigenous rights groups, such as those that already exist in Papua New Guinea, New Zealand and Australia among others.
This week, Australia's Northern Territory imposed a moratorium on seabed mining in its coastal water until at least 2015, where large manganese deposits are believed to exist, to review potential risks.
© Thomson Reuters 2012 All rights reserved