PLATINUM GROUP METALS

NOBLE METALS AND HUMANS

South African platinum dramas continue as Wesizwe top brass is sacked

Top dogs at Wesizwe fired with immediate effect, apparently in connection with disputed bonuses.

Author: Barry Sergeant
Posted:  Tuesday , 03 Nov 2009

JOHANNESBURG - 

WeSizwe, a South African platinum developer, today told the Johannesburg bourse that its CEO, Mike Solomon, and Robert Gordon Rainey, by latest accounts the acting chairman, had stepped down with immediate effect. Nyasha Tengawarima, CFO since 30 June this year, has stepped in as acting CEO "until the board has identified a suitable replacement".

While local media had speculated earlier on Tuesday that something was afoot at Wesizwe, none ventured the possibility that Solomon and Rainey had been involved in a hostile discussion (not between themselves) over bonuses. While this is not a matter that either the company or the individuals would discuss on the record, the information from insiders, there for refutation, is that an amount of R14m was involved.

 

MARKET VALUATION OF OUNCES

 

 

Market

PGM

 

Tier I

Value, USD bn

Resources, Moz

USD/oz

Anglo Platinum

20.187

725.10

27.84

Impala

13.538

325.00

41.66

Lonmin

4.704

158.00

29.77

Tier II

 

 

 

Aquarius

1.955

107.10

18.26

Northam

1.701

120.40

14.13

Eastplats

0.524

74.20

7.06

Anooraq

0.147

110.10

1.34

Developers

 

 

 

Platmin

0.560

17.10

32.76

WeSizwe

0.145

13.00

11.16

PGM

0.150

8.70

17.21

Pt Australia

0.250

5.10

48.97

Jubilee

0.070

50.40

1.38

Totals/average

43.931

1714.20

25.63

Developers

1.174

94.30

12.45

 

Wesizwe officially also announced that "shareholders are advised that the company has received notification that Messrs. Solomon and Rainey intend bringing an application to challenge their removal as directors". Whatever the reason/s, this part of the announcement confirms that their departure was hardly amicable. Apparently four of the seven board directors voted for the pair to be sacked.

Wesizwe has been struggling for months, if not years, to raise capital for its core South African project, Frischgewaagd-Ledig, which made it past the full bankable feasibility study barrier back in March 2008. Measured by stock price performance, Wesizwe is a serial underperformer. Either way, turmoil of a kind continues in the southern African platinum sector, host of 80% of the world's platinum-group-metal (PGM) deposits.

Last month, Fred Roux, one of South Africa's more prominent mining men, was sacked as chairman of global No 2 PGM miner Impala Platinum, by its board of directors. Niall Carroll, apparently in his role as CEO of Royal Bafokeng Holdings, which earns untold millions a year in the form of royalties from Impala, and separately ranks as the biggest shareholder in Impala, played a key role in that story.

On a more positive note, and more recently, Tom Dale was announced as the new CEO at Platmin, the newest platinum producer in southern Africa. The global PGM sector has been in a spin for more than a year, after platinum, palladium and rhodium prices collapsed after mid-2008, along with prices for a number of further byproduct metals cranked out by primary platinum producers, not least nickel. Prices have, of course, recovered well for most of this year.

For its part, Platmin has been funded out of the abyss over the past few years by Pallinghurst Resources; its chairman, Brian Gilbertson, took over as chairman of Platmin, renewing a high level connection with Dale seen between the two a decade and more ago, mainly upon the formation of the modern Gold Fields.

 

Selected platinum stocks

 

 

 

Stock

From

From

Value

Tier I platinum

price

high*

low*

USD bn

Anglo Platinum

ZAR 664.00

-13.6%

80.4%

20.187

Impala Platinum

ZAR 167.96

-22.6%

81.4%

13.538

Lonmin

GBP 14.85

-21.2%

190.1%

4.704

Averages/total

 

-19.1%

117.3%

38.429

Weighted averages

 

-17.9%

89.6%

 

Diversified

 

 

 

 

Anglo American

GBP 22.40

-8.0%

147.2%

49.363

Mvela Resources

ZAR 39.00

-17.4%

151.6%

1.066

Norilsk

USD 13.04

-14.6%

271.5%

24.858

Camec

GBP 0.20

-7.1%

926.3%

0.921

ARM

ZAR 149.00

-11.8%

96.1%

4.034

Xstrata

GBP 8.90

-15.6%

208.2%

42.836

Averages/total

 

-14.7%

398.2%

80.241

Weighted averages

 

-9.5%

175.4%

 

Tier II platinum

 

 

 

 

Stillwater

USD 6.51

-22.0%

269.9%

0.615

Aquarius

GBP 2.58

-20.3%

197.6%

1.955

Northam

ZAR 37.00

-11.5%

124.2%

1.701

NA Palladium

CAD 2.58

-28.3%

126.3%

0.298

Zimplats

AUD 10.84

-1.5%

209.7%

1.053

Eastplats

CAD 0.77

-11.5%

316.2%

0.524

Anooraq

CAD 0.85

-42.6%

286.4%

0.147

Averages/total

 

-19.7%

218.6%

6.294

Weighted averages

 

-16.1%

183.8%

 

Developers and explorers

 

 

 

Platmin

CAD 1.35

-19.6%

321.9%

0.560

WeSizwe

ZAR 1.94

-45.7%

92.1%

0.145

Noront Resources

CAD 1.64

-45.5%

277.0%

0.250

Aquiline

CAD 6.02

-16.3%

736.1%

0.428

Pt Australia

AUD 0.88

-31.3%

122.8%

0.250

Chromex

GBP 0.17

-50.7%

11.9%

0.022

Sylvania

GBP 0.50

-43.1%

107.3%

0.145

Starfield

CAD 0.10

-70.3%

35.7%

0.043

PGM

CAD 1.73

-39.5%

98.9%

0.150

Solitario

CAD 2.40

-14.3%

87.5%

0.067

Colossus Minerals

CAD 4.98

-21.6%

1058.1%

0.330

Jubilee

GBP 0.32

-47.7%

342.1%

0.070

Nkwe

AUD 0.35

-24.2%

245.0%

0.151

Marathon

CAD 1.06

-17.2%

324.0%

0.030

Caledonia

CAD 0.07

-46.2%

180.0%

0.033

Freegold Venture

CAD 0.11

-69.1%

23.5%

0.007

Magma Metals

AUD 0.63

-27.6%

200.0%

0.093

Franconia Minerals

CAD 0.30

-30.2%

200.0%

0.017

Avalon Rare Metals

CAD 2.71

-36.1%

818.6%

0.208

Rusina

AUD 0.09

-37.2%

175.8%

0.025

Largo Resources

CAD 0.18

-20.5%

288.9%

0.035

Macdonald Mines

CAD 0.12

-46.5%

360.0%

0.017

Hard Creek

CAD 0.25

-35.1%

212.5%

0.014

Polymet

CAD 2.75

-23.0%

358.3%

0.357

MetalCORP

CAD 0.18

-30.8%

200.0%

0.008

Wallbridge

CAD 0.23

-17.9%

557.1%

0.023

Benton Resources

CAD 0.42

-38.2%

281.8%

0.027

Mustang Minerals

CAD 0.14

-63.6%

180.0%

0.011

Northern Shield

CAD 0.10

-77.0%

81.8%

0.007

Platina

AUD 0.35

-28.1%

146.4%

0.018

Darnley Bay

CAD 0.15

-25.0%

200.0%

0.008

Pacific NW Cap.

CAD 0.13

-28.6%

150.0%

0.007

Niplats

AUD 0.56

-12.5%

833.3%

0.040

Starcore

CAD 0.11

-41.7%

110.0%

0.006

Huston Lake

CAD 0.24

-58.6%

71.4%

0.008

Goldplat

GBP 0.13

-7.4%

49.3%

0.023

Hinterland Metals

CAD 0.07

-38.1%

550.0%

0.004

Duluth Metals

CAD 1.32

-20.0%

842.9%

0.099

Premium Exp.

CAD 0.20

-63.6%

344.4%

0.009

Eurasia Mining

GBP 0.01

-40.0%

12.5%

0.006

Silvermet

CAD 0.10

-52.5%

533.3%

0.011

Andulela

ZAR 0.14

-60.0%

250.0%

0.007

Developer averages/total

-39.1%

301.8%

3.767

Weighted averages

 

-31.7%

266.2%

 

 

 

 

 

 

Overall averages/total

-33.4%

262.2%

48.490

Overall weighted averages

-19.0%

106.2%

 

* 12-month

 

 

 

 

Source: market data; table compiled by Barry Sergeant

 

 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

Disclaimer

MINEWEB is an interactive publication, with rolling deadlines through each day, commencing in the Sydney morning,  and concluding, 24 hours later,  in the Vancouver evening.  If you believe your side of an issue deserves inclusion, but has failed to meet one of our deadlines, you are invited to notify the Editor in Chief in Johannesburg, and we will include you in our editing and expanding on our stories. Email him at alechogg@gmail.com


Print icon  Print story   Email icon   Email story    Subscribe icon  Subscribe to free newsletter  

BackBack
 
 responses to this article


Name
Subject
Comment

INVESTOR HUB: Platinum group metals



View more charts 


TOP STORIES

MARKET ANALYSIS

Gold to hit $1650 by late 2010, early 2011, but estimate could be low - Jim Sinclair

Sunday , 22 Nov 2009
As a contra to the dollar the outlook for the yellow metal remains strong
More 

FAST NEWS

GOLD RECOVERY CONTINUING FROM MINED ORE

New Gold appeals Mexican gold mine suspension on court ruling